Published May 6, 2024

Incomplete and inconsistent state education policies handcuff the potential of America's gifted students, leading to a loss of human capital and widening excellence gaps across the country. State leaders owe it to students to create comprehensive policies that provide advanced learners across all backgrounds with the quality education they deserve. A promising new roadmap to has the potential to ensure all students, including advanced learners, have ample opportunities to develop their talents and maximize their learning.

Check out more from Chester E. Finn, Jr:

  • Watch "Overhauling the Nation's Report Card" from Chester E. Finn, Jr. here.
  • Watch "Learning Lessons from the Advanced Placement Tests" from Chester E. Finn, Jr. here.
  • Watch "Why Testing and Accountability Matter in K-12 Education" from Chester E. Finn, Jr. here.
  • Read "Time for a Ceasefire in the Civics Wars" from Chester E. Finn, Jr. here.

The opinions expressed on this website are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Hoover Institution or Stanford University. © 2024 by the Board of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior University.

Cast

Chester E. Finn Jr.

Chester E. Finn Jr.

State education policies are neglecting gifted students and wasting their talents. To better ensure that schools help gifted students reach their full potential, states should adopt a new roadmap to provide advanced learners with reliable resources and more opportunities. A recent report from the National Association for Gifted Children shows that incomplete and inconsistent policies are at the heart of the problem.

Ohio, for example, identifies and tracks the scores of gifted students but does not mandate services for them. This especially hurts gifted minority and disadvantaged students who depend on public schooling to develop their talents and maximize their futures. By failing to help these boys and girls realize their potential, we failed to develop America's next generation of leaders and innovators.

State education leaders and policymakers must refocus their support of gifted students by prioritizing continuous student progress, eliminating enrollment barriers that hold back top students. And establishing norms for local gifted programs so that every school serves its top students as well as it serves its underperforming ones. Sound policies include tailored services for the gifted, achievement data reporting, teacher-training and high ability instruction, and consistent student evaluation.

Children ready to accelerate, even ready to skip entire grades, should have that option, and schools should practice flexible grouping of students based on their levels of learning. This comprehensive approach focuses squarely on excellence and equity for gifted learners. If implemented, it can expand talent pools in every state, close demographic excellence gaps, foster upward mobility, and equalize opportunity.

State leaders must ensure that every student can realize their potential.

More from Intellections

Regulations: The Secret Tax Holding America Back

Regulations: The Secret Tax Holding America Back

The Formula For Economic Growth

The Formula For Economic Growth

Revitalizing American Manufacturing

Revitalizing American Manufacturing

School Absenteeism: Missed Days & Missed Opportunities

School Absenteeism: Missed Days & Missed Opportunities

America’s Nuclear Power Revival

America’s Nuclear Power Revival

Rebuilding America’s Maritime Strength

Rebuilding America’s Maritime Strength

Civics Ceasefire

Civics Ceasefire

Students vs. Salaries

Students vs. Salaries

Doing Business with China: Strings Attached

Doing Business with China: Strings Attached

The Exceptional Results of Sensible Teacher Salary Reform

The Exceptional Results of Sensible Teacher Salary Reform

More Like This

The Lapsed Atheist: Charles Murray Makes The Case For God

The Lapsed Atheist: Charles Murray Makes The Case For God

Norway: Defense And Diplomacy In The High North And Beyond

Norway: Defense And Diplomacy In The High North And Beyond

Thomas Sowell Legacy: A Conversation with Justice Clarence Thomas

Thomas Sowell Legacy: A Conversation with Justice Clarence Thomas

Can AI Libel You? The Robby Starbuck Case

Can AI Libel You? The Robby Starbuck Case

Jan Karski

Jan Karski

AI-Powered Business Formation

AI-Powered Business Formation

Complicated Legacy: Jay Bhattacharya On Fauci, RFK, And Vaccines

Complicated Legacy: Jay Bhattacharya On Fauci, RFK, And Vaccines

Iraq: Reform And The Fight For Sovereignty

Iraq: Reform And The Fight For Sovereignty

Securing the Future of Semiconductors

Securing the Future of Semiconductors

Tom Siebel On Education, Reinvention, And The AI Revolution

Tom Siebel On Education, Reinvention, And The AI Revolution

Related

Videos

The Lapsed Atheist: Charles Murray Makes The Case For God

Charles Murray joins Peter Robinson to discuss the evidence that forced him to reconsider God, the soul, and Christianity.

August 17, 2026 • 66 Min Watch

Articles

The Hidden Cause Of The Industrial Revolution

What if the Industrial Revolution began not with steam, but with property rights?

August 17, 2026 • 72 Min Watch

Event

Ideas Uncorked: Reclaiming Liberal Education In America Book Launch

The Hoover Institution in DC hosts Ideas Uncorked: Reclaiming Liberal Education in America Book Launch on Tuesday, September 15 from 5:00-6:30 pm ET. The event will feature Peter Berkowitz and Carl M. Cannon.

September 13, 2024