Why Sanctions Fail and How to Make Them Work

Published July 14, 2026

As Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea work together to challenge the international order, the United States and other free societies must compete with diplomatic, military, and economic tools of statecraft. Sanctions can be an effective tool, but only when they are tied to realistic objectives, rigorously enforced, and integrated into a broader strategy. Sanctions often fail when they become performative, overly broad, poorly enforced, or detached from other elements of national power. Cases involving the Soviet Union, Iraq, Iran, and other regimes show that effective sanctions require clear objectives, rigorous enforcement, humanitarian safeguards, flexibility, and timely action. Used well, they can help deter aggression, constrain hostile regimes, and support those advocating for freedom.

Learn more from H.R. McMaster:

  • Read "Sanctions as a Tool of Economic Statecraft" by H.R. McMaster here.
  • Watch "Today's Battlegrounds" with H.R. McMaster here.
  • Read "Pride, Agency, and Duty: Study America’s Past to Secure Her Future" by H.R. McMaster here.

Learn more about H.R. McMaster here.

__________

The opinions expressed in this video are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Hoover Institution or Stanford University.

© 2026 by the Board of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior University.

 

 

Related

Books

Judgment Calls: Finding the Way to Wise Decisions

How can we make better decisions—especially when the stakes are highest? In Judgment Calls, historian Zachary Shore tackles this timeless puzzle with intellectual daring and uncommon range. 

November 1, 2026

Articles

Strategic Narcissism Is Making A Comeback: The Optimism Of The 1990s And Implications For Today’s Competition With Russia And China

This Monday marks thirty-six years since the beginning of the end of the Cold War. In the excerpt below from Battlegrounds: The Fight to Defend the Free World, I recall watching the Iron Curtain part while serving in the Second Armored Cavalry Regiment, a unit charged with border surveillance and control along the East-West German border and the West Germany-Czechoslovakia border.

November 10, 2026

Articles

Strategika Issue 108: Targeting Civilian Infrastructure

Strategika Issue 108 is now available online. Strategika is an online journal that analyzes ongoing issues of national security in light of conflicts of the past—the efforts of the Military History Working Group of historians, analysts, and military personnel focusing on military history and contemporary conflict.

November 10, 2026